Reviews For Extraneous
You must login () to review.
Reviewer: GeeWay23 Signed [Report This]
Date: 09/04/14 12:48 pm Title: Epilogue: 3 Weeks (II)

.______. Geesss
I really thought I did a review to this AMAZING chap!
I reread it at least a 3 times, I just can't get enough of this. You're one of the best writters that I've ever seen here, I'm glad that Bill and the kids, a long with Tom are fine, and ended up even better for the twins I'm glad they're decided to be a little selfish, it's good for both of them!
Well, I need a sequel as well :D

Author's Response: Thank you so much for that! :D I'm honestly surprised at the praise for what started off as a little project to keep busy.rnrnBeing selfish was definitely a good choice for them at the moment, I agree.rnrnThank you again for such a nice review :)rnrnWe'll definitely see about that sequel ;)

Reviewer: Sieren Signed [Report This]
Date: 08/22/13 10:22 pm Title: Epilogue: 3 Weeks (II)

thanks for this fanfic
it was really really good

are you going to make a sequel?

Author's Response: Thank you for the reviews! They're very much appreciated, truly :) I may consider a sequel

Reviewer: Sieren Signed [Report This]
Date: 08/20/13 05:49 pm Title: Part III: Year 2

i love that chapter
so cute

Author's Response: Thank you :) Year 2 is one of my favorites too!

Reviewer: Sieren Signed [Report This]
Date: 08/20/13 12:36 am Title: Part III: Year 1

:( you skipped a whole year

i want more of the family with baby growing up, not just when the aliens come

maybe do an extra fic of baby adventures later?

i love this story by the way

Author's Response: I love having them with a baby as well, but it would've slowed down the story to include that. Baby adventures sound fun, though. I may do that. :)

Reviewer: Sieren Signed [Report This]
Date: 08/19/13 06:20 pm Title: Part II: Month 6

ROFLMAO
That was great

Author's Response: Thank you :)

Reviewer: Sieren Signed [Report This]
Date: 08/19/13 05:34 pm Title: Part II: Month 5

i really like this story
its really good

Author's Response: Thank you very much :) I'm glad you enjoy it

Reviewer: Gii Way Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/30/13 11:41 am Title: Part I: Tuesday

I'll miss this story! It really was well written!
I'm happy that it's all right and Gustav and Georg are by twins side! And it's good to see the twins opened up to each other!

Author's Response: Thank you so much for the compliment. I'm glad my narrative stayed consistent, as I doubted now and again that the quality was good enough. You're the only one so far to mention the G's. I thought they deserved some final comments on all that was going on. I'm also glad the twins opened up to each other. They seemed to have been on the brink for a few chapters now, and it was nice to see that tension dealt with. Thanks so much for the feedback and, I'll see you next time. :)

Reviewer: Missy P Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/30/13 07:32 am Title: Epilogue: 3 Weeks (II)

Is there going to be a sequel? Just so we can see them like in the future.
It can be like 2 or 3 pages if u don't want to spend a lot of time on it.
I'd really like to see a sequel cos I loved this one

Author's Response: I'm not sure about a sequel just yet. I wouldn't want to run the story into the ground with an unworthy followup. For now, there won't be. Though, I'm flattered that you're so eager to see more. I hope this story will continue to be enough for the time being. :)

Reviewer: GermanOoOGirl Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/30/13 01:39 am Title: Epilogue: 3 Weeks (II)

I'm really happy, that they are together now :) it was the only logical way for their future ( if they should be a happy life ) I thank you very much for the bill x tom end :)

Caleb seems cute. I'm happy that he is healthy and a boy. so they have now 2 sweet kids. hmmmm ... yeah, dont know what so say more xD

I liked the story and i like the end. So thank you for sharing the story with us :) Maybe we read us in a second story ;)

nice greets from germany

Author's Response: In the end, even I couldn't deny the twins needed to be together. You got what you wanted and ultimately so did they.rnrnHaha I enjoy writing their children to be sweet. I always find small children rather sweet so I'm glad they came across that way. rnrnThank you so much for sticking with me and supporting this story. I needed that early support with a story so strange, and it really boosted my confidence to continue. I'm extremely thankful for that. :)rnrnI'll certainly hope to see you next time, whenever that may be. :)

Reviewer: Hexy92 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/29/13 11:08 pm Title: Epilogue: 3 Weeks (II)

nice. even tho i had something different in mind i like it. well, maybe hiding their love would be better for them than showing in out and be happy.
still, i would really like to read more about them

Author's Response: Thanks ;) Ultimately, despite the oddity of the premise in general, I needed there to be a sense of realism. Realistically, they would need to hide for the sake of being able to live their life in relative peace... I'm wary about a sequel out of fear it would ruin the story thus far. Thank you so much for the feedback and, I'll hopefully see you next time. :)

Reviewer: Ninel Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/29/13 11:05 pm Title: Epilogue: 3 Weeks (II)

excellent

Author's Response: Amazing how significant a one-word review can be. Thank you so much. :D

Reviewer: mizu Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/29/13 10:23 pm Title: Epilogue: 3 Weeks (II)

Loved it! This story bordered on some serious tragedy, all the way to the end. It's not exactly an unhappy ending, and not really a happy one. The fact that they've decided to begin a more romantic relationship does not make it fluffy and lighthearted. They HAVE to accept this, so they did. As Tom says, "We wouldn't want it if we didn't have to." Circumstances set them up, and they've decided to make the best of it, even with all the built-in pitfalls. They're together, they'll be together for the rest of their lives, they love each other, so they're going to make it work. No matter that they're uncomfortable and unsure about it themselves. This story was terrific, from beginning to end. There's not enough sci-fi in the world for my taste! And the way you kept the twins platonic til the very end, and then turned it into a touching, sad yet hopeful romance was just perfect. I'm so glad you came back to this and got it finished, and I'm looking forward to seeing more from you!

Author's Response: I always adore reviews from you. Just when I think I've written something less clearly than I could have,  you express exactly what I was trying to portray. I wanted an almost bittersweet, somewhat satisfying ending for the twins that left them more hopeful than they dared to be throughout the rest of the story. Thank you so much for this brilliant review.  I'm flattered, and very happy that you believe I handled such a genre as sci fi which, from what I understand is easy to mess up. You seem to understand the balance of my twins more than most,  and I've been so grateful for that. I hope it's somewhat of a comfort for me to say that I had no intention of abandoning this story.  I'm looking forward to having you as a reader again in the future. And, in the meantime,  you'll be seeing me in your own reviews.  ^_^

Reviewer: Hexy92 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/29/13 11:55 am Title: Epilogue: 3 Weeks (I)

aww....their little family is bigger :) hehehe for sure everything is hard for them and of course Alanna's questions too but i think for Tom this is much harder than for Bill. welll, maybe they should try to change something with their life's and be full happy.

Author's Response: I can understand it coming off as being harder for Tom. I think the Bill character comes unhinged more often than Tom does, so it has more of an impact when he does. I have no doubt they'll be able to make the changes necessary to live as happily as possible. :)

Reviewer: Gii Way Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/29/13 08:52 am Title: Epilogue: 3 Weeks (I)

Good to know that Bill and Caleb are fine! Yeah, now that all nightmare is over they can resolve their in betweens and then finally live their so deserved life!
Soooo awesome you posted! o/

Author's Response: I'm glad they're fine as well. They certainly have a bit more to resolve. I'm glad myself that I was able to update and not leave this story to fall to the wayside incomplete. :)

Reviewer: Ninel Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/29/13 06:25 am Title: Epilogue: 3 Weeks (I)

its soo good that you posted... bonito capi. :)

Author's Response: Thank you so much :)

Reviewer: GermanOoOGirl Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/28/13 02:17 am Title: Part III: Year 5 (VI)

When you'll post the epiloque? :)

Author's Response: I've just posted the first and I'll be posting the next in a few hours, to be certain each one is uploaded properly. So sorry for the wait. :)

Reviewer: mizu Signed [Report This]
Date: 05/26/13 01:29 am Title: Part III: Year 5 (VI)

Ahhh! I'm so glad you're back to writing, I've been waiting for this for a while. what a harrowing ordeal for these boys! Bill seems to be taking this second pregnancy in stride - I'd love to see a couple chapters dedicated to him and Tom going through this one together, since, as much as they didn't want this to happen again, they understand what's happening far more than with the first one, and they seem to be ready for it. It would be nice to see their relationship grow from this interesting platonic/monogamous one into perhaps something more sexual (I know they're not that way in this story, and you've kept the balance so nicely as I've mentioned before, but seeing as they live like a couple, have had sex and not just on the alien ship - Bill's going to be going through "that time" again - and they have a child together and one on the way, plus all the love they feel for one another and everything they've been through, it would be a lovely segue for them. And your readers!). This has been one heck of a journey you've taken us on, sometimes damned painful, which shows that you know how to draw the reader in. Thank you for coming back to this, and I hope everything's smoothing out for you so that you can continue to write!

Author's Response: Thank you so much for the lengthy review. I wish I had answered it in a more timely manner but, this story's been giving me so much trouble, it was easier to take the coward's way and avoid THF altogether. You did give me a lot to think about while writing, however, and I did take it all into account while working on the epilogue. I'm glad you understand the twins' dynamic here; I've tried so hard to keep it in balance, but they've been teetering the scale for some time now. I suppose we'll see how that turns out. I'll be honest; dedicating several chapters to contentment and subtle angst might not be my thing; as I tried and every character went haywire from their established characterization. Though, it will certainly be something to practice with more in my next THF some time from now. Thank you so much for your continued support. I greatly appreciate it. :)rnrn--Gabbi

Reviewer: Gii Way Signed [Report This]
Date: 05/25/13 12:52 pm Title: Part III: Year 5 (VI)

NEEEEIIIIN IT CAN NOT BE THE LAST!!! .___.

I wasn't expecting you to post this soon. I LOVED this chap, it's sad but happy at the same time!

it'll have a sequell, right??? say yeeesss bitteee!

Author's Response: I'm glad you enjoyed the chapter; and the story in general, judging from that reaction to the announcement. Haha. I'm not sure about a sequel. I won't write it off entirely, but, I'm not sure I can continue this plot past this story... Thank you for your review; I really do appreciate it.rnrn--Gabbi

Reviewer: Hexy92 Signed [Report This]
Date: 05/25/13 09:58 am Title: Part III: Year 5 (VI)

sad to tell but i can't wait to read the epilogue, even if i would like to read more about them. i'm happy tho that everything is good with them and really can't wait for more

Author's Response: Thank you so much for all of that. Yeah, everything is drawing to a steady close; though, there will be plenty more developments to read about them in the epilogue. :)

Reviewer: Ninel Signed [Report This]
Date: 05/25/13 06:29 am Title: Part III: Year 5 (VI)

great capi.so bill is pregnan again.. :) the most important is they are all fine ...... yehhhhhhhhhhh now waiting for the next cap. :D

Author's Response: Bill is indeed pregnant. :) They'll all have a little more to deal with before they're fine but, they've certainly survived the ordeal of a story I've put them through.

You must login () to review.