Date: 07/05/10 11:06 am Title: Chapter 9
i think you need some crackers to go with it but i liked it.
Date: 07/05/10 02:17 am Title: Chapter 9
Hunny you have to write MORE. That was such a short chapter ;P
But I loved it... Poor Bill :(
I wonder what will happen next.
Close close friends have 'romantic friendships'. And it was the boys in this have. I have one with my BFF (: :3 though people think we're going out - we're not. ;P
And, it was a very nice chapter.
Write more for chapters though XD Was this like.. 700 words? o_O XD
Date: 05/31/10 10:27 pm Title: Chapter 8
glad to see this back!
Date: 05/28/10 11:43 am Title: Chapter 8
Bill is...kinky, he's bleeding like a madman still and he wants another round, that's fucking hot or i'm just sick, either way, i'm loving it
poor Tom, so excited and went the wrong way haha
awesome chapter
Date: 05/19/10 04:33 pm Title: Chapter 7
I like this very, very much.
Date: 05/19/10 12:13 pm Title: Chapter 7
that was sick and twisted but so fucking hot!! i feel like a psycho for loving this story this much
i knew Bill was a kinky bastard, i knew it
oooh Bill is gonna find out Tom's the Phantom!!
amazing chapter
Date: 05/19/10 11:52 am Title: Chapter 7
*sends Bill and Tom to first-aid lessons so that they know you should never use towels or any other type of absorbent cloth to stem the blood flowing out of a wound* XD
Wow, SERIOUSLY wasn't expecting Bill to have a sadomasochism kink. o.O That totally struck out of the blue! XD Is all their sex gonna be RAWR like that? :P
And oh noes!!! Is Bill smart enough to put two-and-two together and realize Tom is the Phantom?! :O DUN DUN DUN!
Date: 05/19/10 07:44 am Title: Chapter 7
Whoa there, Bill ;) lol
Yeah, so, I love you. THANK YOU!
Date: 05/19/10 05:11 am Title: Chapter 7
Lol.. Bill's most likely gonna find out the truth now :
Date: 05/19/10 01:33 am Title: Chapter 7
you did good! but now you have to update soon because you left us with a cliffhanger... and i want to see how tom gets out of the bonfire comment!!
Date: 05/16/10 11:02 pm Title: Chapter 1
Awww! :D My fics really aren't that great though, all of them have HUGE, GLARING flaws, way worse than this fic does. XD
(Speaking of, I have to say I was hoping Tom would rub his budding relationship with Bill into Becca's face, but oh well. XD Maybe he's just too nice. :P)
Author's Response: well, the "huge glaring flaws" that you speak of are rarely apparent to me XD and as for Tom, perhaps i could work in a little "rubbing in" :)
Date: 05/16/10 10:24 pm Title: Chapter 1
*phew* I'm glad you didn't take offense to my review. ^^ I was so scared you were going to be mad at me and I was like, 'PLEASE don't let her be angry D:' because there are some authors who get touchy about stuff. XD A friend of mine recently told an author that she liked her story but she should get a beta for her grammatical errors. The author freaked out, cried, deleted all her fics, and ended up calling my friend to whine and cry about it. I was like, ._. WTF, SRSLY?
Author's Response: are you kidding me? wow, yeah, i definitely do not take offense to any kind of constructive criticism because i totally understand that nobody's writing can be absolutely on the mark 100% of the time...oh and by the way, I am secretly a huge huge fan of yours because all your fics are incredible :)
Date: 05/16/10 01:43 pm Title: Chapter 6
Finally got WiFi again so I can review this. XD I have to say I L.O.V.E. this story. I love the plot and the writing and the character interactions. There's just one weeny thing niggling at me, and that's Becca. (who isn't important now anyway, but eh. XD) What bothers me is that she comes out and says she has an affair going on, seems pleased about it, and makes a point of saying she was only with Tom for the money and that she hated his personality.
However, in earlier chapters, Becca is possessive and controlling, and she always seems to want Tom around. She constantly picks at him about Bill because she's jealous Tom may like Bill, she calls him all the time and demands he come home on time and not stay out. If she doesn't like him and is only in it for the money, why does she do these things? Why does she care about seeing him and talking to him? Why does she care if Tom likes Bill? She's just a gold-digger, not in it for hanging around Tom.
The whole affair thing seems a little too convenient here. The timing is too perfect and it seems like an easy fix to get her out of the picture so we can have more Tom/Bill action. Which is fine, if you want to go that way. But it doesn't match up with her earlier actions. She seems like a completely different person here, and it doesn't ring true.
The way I see it, there's two ways to write her character. Either you stick with the affair thing (which gives you an easy out when you need it) and change her earlier personality, or you stick with her original actions and find some other reason for them to break up. If you go with the first one, I'd suggest that you make her seem a bit more secretive, and more selfish. Maybe she only calls Tom when she needs money. Maybe whenever he tries to call her, he can't get ahold of her. Things like that. Make her seem a little suspicious so the affair thing doesn't come out of the blue and seem a bit off-key with the rest of her character. If you go the other way, maybe you can make Tom realize she's a leech and dump her. XD (An easy way to do this would be to give her a gambling problem)
I think you tried to make her have as many annoying characteristics as possible (which is common in slashfic, not a big deal) but they ultimately clashed and made her seem a little fake and overdone. It's fine to have a character designed to be hated, but make sure their nasty little flaws all line up nicely. :3
That's the only thing that bothers me, and it's in a minor character anyway. XD Something to think about if you ever chose to re-write this. :D Over-all, great job so far! :D
Author's Response: you know, i paid such little attention to becca while writing this (i know, that sounds kind of bad haha) that i didn't even notice her actions weren't lining up, so thank you bunches for pointing that one out, your review was quite helpful :)
Date: 05/15/10 07:49 pm Title: Chapter 6
yay!!! the bitch is gone but that's one hell of a way for her to go. the Phantom should burn her house down
awwww Bill is so good to Tom, i love it!
Date: 05/14/10 03:16 pm Title: Chapter 6
thank god that bitch is gone but she shouldnt have cheated on tom...
Date: 05/14/10 12:21 pm Title: Chapter 6
OOOHHHHHHHH NO YOU DIDNT BITCH... *rage*
...buuuuuut that does leave things nicely open for a certain officer...
Date: 05/14/10 08:21 am Title: Chapter 6
Oo.. the suspense
Date: 05/14/10 07:22 am Title: Chapter 6
Never had any good feelings about one. Bad egg, lol :3 She was amusing, to say the least, tho
*coos at screen* Bill opening doors for Tom.... yeah, LOVE YOU. :) And Bill`s "Officer voice" lol :) could you make this fic any better? :D
danke for updating so quickly! i love it
