Date: 03/17/10 08:49 pm Title: Chapter 9 - Eternity
I think it was fine. I enjoyed it a lot and I like how it was such a nice set ending. I wasn't disappointed at all, you were brilliant! =] Nice job and I truly enjoyed myself.
Author's Response: Thank you so much :D I'm glad you liked it and that the ending was good enough! Thanks!
Date: 03/17/10 08:15 pm Title: Chapter 8 - Vox Dei
Great chapter, and no I don't feel it was unrealistic at all. Aw, thank you for thanking me lol. I really love this story and I think you're a great author. I'm excited for the next story too =]
Date: 03/17/10 06:08 pm Title: Chapter 9 - Eternity
YOU CAN'T LEAVE IT AT THAT! I FUCKING LOVE YOU FOR THIS AND I'LL LOVE YOU ETERNALLY. YOU THINK YOU'RE NOT SO GOOD BUT HOW WRONG YOU ARE, YOU REALLY DON'T KNOW. I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY THIS STORY WASN'T MUCH REVIEWED, BUT PLEASE KNOW...PLEASE KNOW I HAVEN'T READ A STORY LIKE THIS IN AGES, AGES. JEEZ. THANK YOU .
Fine, I'm done with capital letters. But you're a genius. You don't seem to know. But you should feel more confident in what you write, I think. You're just amazing, amazing, amazing. I really fell in love with your writing.
Okay, I'm retracting some of the things I said: I said I may not like Alex, WRONG! I like her. I like the role she's having in this story, and even if she kissed Bill, it didn't really seem like she was being a slut, it's obvious that she has great feelings inside of her for both the twins, and I...and I'm speechless...
The way you ended up this story (I am so looking forward to seeing the next one!), it's perfect in my eyes, with a cliffhanger that's probably killing me, I know that this story will be all I'll think of until I know how things will go.
And you were right though...I said I'd like Bill to keep himself maybe a little distant from Tom...the way you described it, it seems like Bill did find his twin again, and yet he still was a new person. I don't know. It just felt like that to me, which is why, I think, you're an amazing writer. I don't understand why you said you're not so good at writing relationships. You really should try Slash sometime--it'd be so f*****g good.
Tom's reaction left me taken aback. A little girly maybe--but that's okay, seriously, I don't mind, it's not that he could punch Bill after all, could he? Really, I don't mind it, and the ending was superbe, and like I said I can't wait to see what will happen next.
If this story is completed, though, you should click on YES when it says "complete", lol. So, this will be a series. What a series. Seriously.
As for your previous response, I don't know whether you received my email, but I assure you it's okay, I took no offence for what you said, actually I barely noticed it. I hope you've stopped worrying, seriously, don't trouble yourself.
Then. Thanks again for sharing this awesome story. You have no idea how I enjoyed it--how I loved it, every single part of it, how I fell in love with your style and how I adore your ideas. I really, really, really am looking forward to reading the next part (3rd time I say so, I know, I know).
I know I mostly babbled. I'm so sorry. But...ah. I really loved it so much. Then again. You seem to need to hear this so many times: you really are talented, talented. I expect to read so many more of your works! I'll be right here waiting. :D
See youuuuuuu!
Author's Response: Oh my God, thank you so much! I'm so, so glad that you liked the ending, and hell, you even like Alex, which is even better! God, I'm so happy I didn't let you down with this, you have no idea how glad I am that you liked it! So, this is gonna be my massive, huge THANK YOU that pretty much thanks you for absolutely everything you've said throughout this story - THANK YOU!!! I think genius is a bit much :) But I'm glad you liked it :D
The next part should be up by the weekend, so that should make up for the evil cliffhanger at the end of this, lol. And yes, I agree that Tom's reaction does seem a little girly :D I wasn't sure how he'd react, so I just sort of winged it, lol. I hope it's realistic enough XD
Thank God I didn't offend you, I was so worried I had. Aww man, but it's so nice of you to have read this story right through even though its a het and stuff...wow :D I love everything you've said about this story, and I love you for being so awesome and always writing great reviews! THANK YOU AGAIN!!
Not much left to say now :) Except that I hope the next part is just as good, and that you enjoy that too! I've got another story in the works too that's just a General, not a het or a slash, but hell, I might try a slash anyway!
Last time - THANKS!! See ya!!
Date: 03/16/10 06:53 pm Title: Chapter 8 - Vox Dei
Oh. Okay, so, first off, I knew that this story would come to an end someday (lol, it always happens), but even if there are two more stories, I already know I'll miss this one so painfully. It has passed such a long time since I last loved a story the way I love this one, I think about it so often, and everytime I grow so impatient, and I can't really wait to see what Bill will do. I can't remember ever clicking so impatiently and so often on Recent Stories to find a new update.
So...one more chapter to go then. Let me just say that I extremely loved how you described the whole chapter, and Bill's memories coming back. Well, some of them. It practically brought tears to my eyes.
"Bill, she had been screaming, I love you." - that's where tears started...
"He was his brother. His twin. His person with whom he had always been, who was everything he was, and was still so much more." - ...and that's where they got worse. It was so heartbreaking, and so well described. I did tell you you're extremely good at writing, and I think (I think) you've got a potential you don't seem to be aware of, after all. But believe me, you really are persuasive and convincing. I'll never stop saying how I love your writing.
Which is why I can't help but TSK! when you say you don't write relationships very well. You don't...write relationships...very well? EH?! Are you crazy, woman? You are a perfect at writing them! I don't know whether it's a matter of natural talent or experience, but you managed to keep me hooked even if I don't read Het. Which says something.
Well...the chapter has a slow pace and it wasn't very long, so I think I've said pretty much everything. But I'm waiting for the next story to come. I'm so curious to see where this is leading. Oh God. The wait is almost killing me.
Oh, one thing. So apparently Bill remembered Tom as his twin, well, I'm sorry for my nasty comments, I'm so happy he did. Really. And I don't even mind it being just a normal relationship between brothers and not a twincest, lol. I would've never expected that. I can't wait until tomorrow, I already know I'll have my eyes glued to the screen all the night.
And lmaooo, is it so obvious that I'm not a native speaker? Lmao, as long as everything I want to say comes off in an understandable way, I guess it's alright. Just in case, I'm italian, so...errr I don't know how to explain myself...so, if in the UK it's nine in the evening, over here it's ten. And so on. I hope that was clear (I know it wasn't), so, well, thanks, the oral test was fine, lol. So basically...there's not that much of a difference between our timings. I don't know how that matters. But there isn't.
As for a Slash story. Just write it. There's always a first time, and even if it doesn't come off particularly stunning, it will be beautifully written regardless, so! Well, my advice is: write and post. But surely you're free to do what you prefer.
Lol, you want to know what's very funny at the moment? I'm listening to an italian song now that says "the truth is, when I was a child, music saved me." Ironic! It's only a random song I've just found...
Soooo...see you in the review for the last chapter, I guess? Mmmh, maybe I'm too emotional but it's making me really sad. :( Oh my...I'll live.
Great chapter, as always.
Author's Response: First, I've really got to apologise for the way I phrased that "I keep forgetting you're not a native speaker". I am SO sorry, I hope I didn't offend you! That was so tactless of me! Your English is perfect, it's not obvious at all that you're not a native speaker. Oh God I hope I'm not digging a deeper hole! I'm so sorry if that was offensive! *Please forgive me*
Anyway (sorry...), I'm glad that you're still liking this story and that you're sticking with it even though it's not what you usually read :) And again, thank you so much for everything you've said, particularly in this review XD Your messages always make me smile, you've always been really helpful and I hope (I know I keep saying this) that the ending doesn't disappoint :)
Hmm, I didn't know the time difference was so short. Maybe I should have payed more attention in Geography, lol. I've never heard any Italian music (except a band called DNR, but I think they sing in English :D), is there anything you recommend? I like to listen to all sorts of stuff, regardless of language. Just a question :)
And your comments weren't nasty at all, I appreciate everything you've said, even the twincest stuff, lol. Once again - I AM SO SORRY!!!! I'm desperately praying that I didn't offend you with the English thing!!
The last chapter should be here either tonight or tomorrow, so I hope you like it. Glad the test went well :) And as for the slash story, I've been jumping about between fanfics at the moment, so I think I'll finish off unendlichkeit, then upload the next part of it(this sounds really confusing :S) and simultaneously upload the other fanfic I'm working on. That's just a General story, no relationships whatsoever :)
Thanks so much!!
And SORRY AGAIN!!!
Date: 03/16/10 02:37 pm Title: Chapter 7 - Vox Populi
Really, it's finishing that fast? Or is it just the end of this segment? Are you doing a sequel? or...I'm confused. I liked this chapter though, and I am excited to see what's going on between everyone here.
Author's Response: Yeah, only two more chapters on this story left, I'll be uploading the next one in literally ten minutes :) But yes, there's going to be two more stories dealing with the same plot, the second story is pretty short, mainly because it deals with a much more serious issue and I didn't want to drag it out too long, but the third part is pretty long at the moment. Thank you so much for the support, and I hope I don't let you down with what I plan on doing within this story! I need to figure out how do the series thing on this website and how to put stories into the same serie first :D Lol, Thank you!
Date: 03/16/10 02:24 pm Title: Chapter 6 - Responsibility
Wow, definitely will be interesting to see how he reacts with Alex. Oh, and I wanted to tell you that you do a great job of writing Tom's letters to the fans and the comments the fans leave, it all sounds so realistic.
Date: 03/16/10 02:14 pm Title: Chapter 5 - Selfish
There is absolutely nothing wrong with long chapters lol. I can't imagine getting amnesia, just no, I wouldn't want to. I really like the way you're going with this too. You're a great author and you definitely should keep up the beautiful work. Oh, and I love your title, it's what drew me in really because I love the song.
Author's Response: Hey, thanks so much! I'm glad you're enjoying the story, and I really appreciate the support! I thought the song was appropriate because of what it translates to, but also because of the power behind the song. Perfectly executed and beautifully sung :) Thanks again!
Date: 03/16/10 01:54 pm Title: Chapter 4 - Blameless
I really do love how it's progressing, it's not too fast or too slow. I am excited to see how Bill's memories come back...if they come back that is.
Date: 03/16/10 02:27 am Title: Chapter 3 - Confusion
Poor Tom. Nice word choice too =] I'm definitely interested.
Author's Response: Thanks so much for all three of your reviews :) I'm glad you like it and are interested, so thank you again!
Date: 03/16/10 02:03 am Title: Chapter 2 - Curiosity
I like the opening quotation. It's good so far, I don't understand your lack of reviews really.
Date: 03/16/10 01:56 am Title: Chapter 1 - In Rememberance
Interesting. I like the fact your writing is good and I don't see any glaring mistakes. I believe this is going to be interesting.
Date: 03/15/10 06:14 pm Title: Chapter 7 - Vox Populi
Hey, bb. I'm practically over exhausted, not to mention that I'm terrified because tomorrow I've got this huge oral test about Science, for which I'm so not ready, so this is probably going to be short.
However, there we go again. Another cliffhanger, as you pointed out. Thank you, eh, seriously! (I was kidding ;P).
Anyways...I don't think I'll need to read more chapters to understand where you're going, I already know it, it's kind of obvious, Bill is falling in love with Alex. And if speaking of love is premature, then he's definitely interested in her. When I asked if he was jealous, I actually I meant jealous of Tom, not of Alex, ;P. So yeah, then he really was jealous, yeah?
But then, I don't get it all. He seems to be interested in her, or has he understood that there's something more (IS THERE something more?) and he wants to know what it is? Well...if he's right, and there's actually something more that Tom is keeping from him (bad, bad, bad brother), then he's quier clever, eh? *pets Bill*
I'm liking Bill. I hope he'll become more and more independent from now on, he deserves it.
I don't know how to take this to be honest. I don't read much Het anyways, and when I do it's because...well...I don't read Het, haha, so you better expect some aggressive twincester-like comments from now on. And they'll probably be out of place considering that this story is not a Slash in the slightest. :|
Oh well. Like I told you, I'm going to follow you all through this, so don't worry if I do get jealous, lol. I already love it very much.
Sticking with the love triangle subject, in your last response you said: "Correct me if I'm wrong, but I put Bill/Tom/OFC cause it suggests a love triangle, not a Bill/Tom and someone on the side, lol. Is that right?"
You really have to be patient with me. I'm extremely tired tonight and I want to cry at the thought of all those beast pages that are awaiting me, and plus, I'm not English, I'm just a learner (tell me when I'm not clear), so I didn't exactly get what you meant there. But basically, yes, Bill/Tom/OFC is a love triangle, that's what it suggests. Which is why I'm telling you that's why I THINK that Bill is quickly falling for Alex.
There's something else. Something that actually I haven't considered so far, so you've kind of anticipated me again, ;)
So, Bill is still Tom's biological twin, but what about now, now that he's lost his memory, do they share the same thoughts again? Apparently, Bill is already keeping his own thoughts from Tom, isn't he? And he didn't even feel so guilty doing so! I wonder where this is leading. So will he be distant from Tom now, not his twin brother anymore? Oh, I couldn't be happier. Lol, I was kidding (NO I WAS NOT), of course Tom deserves his brother back (NO HE DOES NOT), and nobody has to be jealous because of Alex being there (SHOULDNT SHE MIND HER OWN BUSINESS?), and besides, Bill might not remember his life at all and become a different new person. And the scene where Bill couldn't understand what Alex and Tom were saying because the genius was speaking with her in English? How willingly would I have strangled him? Haha, that's pretty much what I meant by "out of place comments." Of course I *rationally* understand that Tom must be exhausted by this whole situation, so he needs his girlfriend by his side. I know, I know!
Ohhh I'm intrigued now. I really can't wait to see how Bill will do in the end.
No, okay, basically, I'd really like to see Bill getting himself a new life if that's what you want to write. Seriously, I can't think of nothing else, but you'll see I'll like it.
And I've completely gone off of the point btw. I told you I'm tired.
...not enough tired to be able to read this anyways, :D
I can't help but think that I'll miss a lot when it will be finished. Oh well...at least you'll post the sequel, right?
...how about writing a Slash?
(I was kidding, lol).
Oh, as for your responses. Really, don't you worry, as long as I can make them out! :P
Bye!
Author's Response: Yeah, I'm not known for my subtlety with relationships :) I told you I don't write them very well, lol. Thank you for sticking by my story, I'm glad you still like it even though it's not what you normally read. It's so awesome that you can take the time to read something that's completely different from what you usally read AND to take the time to review it as well! Basically - you're awesome, and I'm so grateful :)
There could be something more to this Alex, Tom, Bill thing...but that's not really explored much until the last chapter ;) About the keeping thoughts from Tom...let's just say that (if I don't ruin it too much with the next few parts, lol) Bill does start getting a little distant from Tom for quite a few reasons :) Oh, and by the way, I'm sorry I keep forgetting you're not a native speaker, so if my responses get really hard to understand, just cyber-punch me or something :D Sorry!
I hope I don't let you down with what I have planned in this story, the next chapter should clear most of it up, so...*panic* I've already written out what's gonna happen *more panic* so I hope you like it!!
I hope you did okay with your test today (I assume it's today, I'm not sure what the time difference is between where I am and where you are lol) but if it's not until later GOOD LUCK!!!! I'd have said that last night but I posted the chapter at nine o'clock my time, then I was lazy and went to bed early :) I hope you did (or do) well!
THANK YOU AGAIN!!!!
Oh, on a final note, I'd be interested in writing a slash, probably between Bill and Tom (lol) but I really have no idea how to approach it, and since I'm no good at relationships (especially of the slash type) I'd probably screw it up, lol. Oh well! I have a couple more stories in mind and I wrote the first chapter for a new story last night...AGH, so many ideas! LOL, THANK YOU!
Date: 03/14/10 04:35 pm Title: Chapter 6 - Responsibility
And there we go again with another cliffhanger. Owh. Believe me, I'd love to tell you what I think of Alex, I'd really love to, but there just isn't enough information of her, yet. So ehm...nice name, lol. I like the name Alex. But it was nice to see her speak. Everytime I see one of them being in love with a girl it feels a little weird, I admit it (am I too much of a fangirl? Probably), so I can't really say at the moment whether I like Alex or not...sorry!!
Still speaking of Alex, there's something you should know. "Pairing" doesn't mean general interaction between two characters, you know that, right? So, if Bill and Tom's relationship is not a twincest, then you should remove the pairing Bill/Tom. If the only pairing is Tom/Alex, then the story is Het. But I don't think Gen.
I was speaking about pairings and all that because I want to link it back to the Alex-subject; so what do I have to expect from Tom/Bill/OFC? Oh my God. That's killing me. What if I'll just be too jealous? What if I'll be unfair? What if I'll...okay, enough. I won't surely stop reading because of that. Though I bloody hope I'll accept Alex, since she seems to be a good girl, considering that Tom loves her so much.
I pondered over Bill/Tom/OFC. Mmmh. So...has Alex been Bill's girlfriend, too? Just wondering. Or...will he fall in love with Alex now? You don't exactly have to answer, lol. I understand that you can't give anything away. I'm just babbling, haha.
Though I can't help but think; did Bill feel a little jealous when he saw Tom holding Alex' hand? I can't help but think that, since he scowled at her. But then again, YOU LEFT IT WITH A CLIFFHANGER, so. Haha, I'm kidding, of course.
Whatever, if Bill doesn't like her anyway, he's gonna be my favourite character. Lol, I'm kidding. See? I'm being a bitch.
Okay, enough speaking about Alex. Let's move on to Tom. His despair is palpable, so I can pretty much understand why he needs Alex so much. Poor thing, he must be shattered. He doesn't seem to going through all that too well (well, considering that it's all pretty new to him...), and I admit that whenever the story focuses some paragraphs on Tom's inside, I can't help some tears. They haven't exactly poured out, yet, but it's really being so heartbreaking for me too. Very sad. I can't help but wonder what you have planned for this story.
And then. I missed Bill's POV. It's really good to see how far everything feels to him, and I couldn't help but feel (how many times have I said "and I can't help but...' in this review?!?) a little annoyed when Simone was stroking his hair. *Personally*, if she was a stranger to me, I wouldn't let her touch me, despite the fact that I'd be well aware that that might kill her. So well, yeah, Bill is a nice boy, considering that he's started calling her 'mother'. Good good good boy. *pets Bill*
I know that basically this review lacks constructive and concrete criticism. Like pretty much all my other reviews that I've left for this story. It's just that I've got nothing to complain about, seriously, I'm enjoying it the way it is! I'll be okay with anything you'll write, I promise. And you'll see it won't be such a big deal if I don't like Alex, haha.
As I said, it's all getting really painful, and you keep things so...slow...and...gradual...that I'm sure I'm getting more and more hooked on this. I can understand that's a good thing, but I'm going impatient here, lolz. Probably, in a short time I'll just be saying "WHERES THE NEXT UPDATE!!!".
Or something like that. If I ever degenerate that way, promise me you'll virtually slap me.
I'm so glad you managed to update this even if it was mother's day. :]
Author's Response: First things first, I'm gonna see if I can get this response to show up properly instead of being one big huge paragraph like the last few have been! If it doesn't work, I apologise in advance for all the random little characters that appear where there should be a line break, lol :)
rnI like the name Alex too, as a girl's name, hopefully the information given in the next chapter will be a little more helpfully :D Also, I removed the Gen genre, since I read the submission guidelines and it says it can't be a general if there's a pairing, so I'll remove the Bill/Tom one as well and replace it with Tom/OFC and Bill/Tom/OFC. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I put Bill/Tom/OFC cause it suggests a love triangle, not a Bill/Tom and someone on the side, lol. Is that right?
rnOn the same subject, I think the Bill/Tom/OFC thing doesn't really come into it until the very end, leading into the next part. Oh, I got that wrong by the way, there are actually nine chapters, not eight, but there are still two more stories in the same series to come so...hopefully *fingers crossed* those'll help expand the story some more and explain the pairings.
rnI'm glad you're liking Tom's sections. Personally, I find it much more interesting to write about Tom and how he feels, though I'm not really sure why. I think it's because Tom always seems a little more detached in interviews (like in interview above the clouds, THTV, he talks about how Bill always gets emotional at films, but he never does:) So I like to imagine how Tom would really react in that situation.
rnAbout the constructive criticism, there's no lack of it whatsoever :D It's all been really helpful, especially when I've been proof-reading my chapters in preparation for posting! Everything you've said has been helpful! I keep saying that, lol, but it's true.
rnI'll be updating tomorrow with the next chapter. Since there's only three chapters left, things start to move a little faster (I think, anyway). If I get a chapter a day up, then the last chapter will be online by wednesday, so...*fingers crossed again* :) Then onto the next part!
rnI forgot to say at the start, but no way, it's not fangirly at all to think it's strange to see (or read) about one of them with a girl, lol. I don't really write relationships all that way, so I think I'll be really lucky if I pull this off!
rnAnyway, thanks so much, and I hope tomorrow's chapter will be a little more helpful in terms of how the story is going. And about the jealousy thing...;) Maybe, lol.
rnTHANK YOU!!! I hope the paragraphs worked this time. If not, I'm stumped. I have no idea how to fix it, lol.
rnTHANK YOU AGAIN!
Date: 03/13/10 01:02 pm Title: Chapter 5 - Selfish
(Yes, this is a repost, because I suddenly realised I had something to say and I forgot about it). Okay, so. First things fist, like you always say, I'm sorry I even considered overestimating your writing. No, I definitely wasn't overrating anything here. If anything, I wonder why I'm still the only reader, to be honest. You deserve more, tons more. But I guess this is how beginnings usually are, and I'm so glad you're keeping this up. :)
When I saw no update these last hours, I admit I got a little worried, but this chapter made me feel a lot better, lol.
So...it's going more and more interesting, isn't it? I...don't exactly like crying in front of the screen, because I feel slightly stupid and in all honesty, when a story makes me sad, I dwell on depression for days and my chest feels incredibly heavy after that. It's not that this chapter was particularly tragic, but tears poured out nonetheless, especially when I read Tom's message to the fans. Touching. Maybe it was also because while I was reading, the song "Come Home" (Eyes Set To Kill) was playing, and when she would sing "so come home" it kind of reminded Tom's situation here, lol.
Bill is incredibly tender; my heart just breaks whenever I think of him and his hard situation, and whatever he’s going through. I totally, completely, utterly loved you at a specific point: when Tom shows Bill the pictures, Bill doesn’t say “that’s me,” instead he thinks “that’s the man in the mirror.” Seriously, brilliant, ingenious, smart. I was totally blown away by what Bill thought.
Which is why I’m pretty much retracting what I said in the previous review (and this is something that happens when you’re reading a story little by little, you may change your mind during the reading): no, there’s nothing rushed. Probably he just had to be calm in front of Tom, considering, like I said, that he couldn’t rely on anybody else, and I understand how frustrated, confused, and scared he must be. So no, it didn’t sound out of place for him to attack Tom some chapters ago, and then being civil; in fact it completely makes sense that now he still doesn’t accept the way he appears. Seriously…I don’t know what else I can say to let you know how I’m loving this.
So there seems to be no way to get Bill back. Is this a hint at what's coming next, or was the last sentence meant to be just being misleading? Lol, I guess I'm going to find out soon.
As for my personal hopes...(WARNING: DO NOT CHANGE ANYTHING in the story because of my expectations!!)...so, if Bill doesn't come back, it would be so interesting to read how he gets a new life, all to himself, obviously. In that case, I don't expect him to want Tom around for much longer, it'd be too painful for him.
If, instead, he does come back, then I suspect this Alex will have to show up sooner or later. Will he remember about his life as soon as he'll see Alex' face? That's what I keep wondering. Lol I'm still waiting for her to appear, I'm genuinely curious.
As for the "through the monsoon" part, and considering what you said, ahhhhh, okay, now I get what you meant! I apologise for pointing out that monsoon part so harshly, I didn't mean to. I should've waited for this to come, sure. Lol, only as long as it doesn't get too much, but if Bill HAS TO remember his life, please don't use lyrics excessively. :) Just an advice.
Oh oh oh! You apologise for the length of the chapter?! No! Absolutely no, don’t, hell, long chapters are the best thing ever invented! Okay, I’m exaggerating. But still! Yes, it was longer than usual, I really was lost in the story!
I'm getting...more and more hung up on this, in fact. Seriously. When you said there are going to be eight chapters my heart missed one beats or two and I kind of thought, "damn. What am I going to do when it's done?". Will you write some other Tokio Hotel stories, yes? I don't mean to bug you, absolutely, but I'd love to see more of your works, really. Any chance I can? Even through email, MSN, whatever else, if I'm not being too intrusive? Whenever you want? Whatever you want? And even if they don't concern Tokio Hotel? Lol, there were a lot of questions.
Haha, I loved what you said, you stay online for hours waiting for me to review. But really, don't, I proper fail at being prompt sometimes.
Oh! One last thing: I think there's something you should change. I think that a story cannot be Gen AND Het or Slash at the same time, so I'd remove Gen, and I would add Slash, too, considering that the main pairing is Tom/Bill. :)
I'm falling in love with it and your writing always more and more. :)
Author's Response: I have to say, every time I read something you've written about my story, it makes me feel so pleased, even if it's just one person reading and reviewing, it's so amazing knowing that that one person is enjoying it! I'm so glad, so my first thank you for this review! rnrn Now, onto the rest :) I didn't get chance to update thursday because I came home from college and had a TON of stuff to do, and I really had to get all that out of the way first! Then I was proof-reading this chapter and that took a while, since I had somehow managed to mess up the order of it *confusion*. rnrn Second, I love that song too! Come Home by ESTK is one of my favourites off their latest album, I think they're an amazing band :) Just had to agree with you on that one, it's such a moving song. I usually listen to music when I write, and I try to listen to the right stuff when I'm dealing with certain moods...but sometimes it doesn't always work! Usually, the quote you see at the top of the chapter is the song I was listening to when I started writing it :) rnrn I'm glad you liked the "man in the mirror" :) I figured it would be more appropriate than "Oh, it's me." And no worries about the other review, they've all been really helpful and, like I keep saying, really awesome at boosting my confidence! I can't thank you enough!rnrn As for Alex, I wouldn't say that she was a memory cue, but she sort of helps...I can't say much more without giving it away :) I think Alex appears in the next chapter, so I guess I'll be holding my breath to see what you think. I don't think I go on too much about her, since the main pairing is between Tom and Bill. rnrn I think I only quoted from one more TH song in the penultimate chapter, but I can't explain why without giving it away again! :D I'm praying it will all come together well that it'll be (mostly) cleaned up at the end...rn Which brings me to my last point. There's only eight chapters in "Unendlichkeit", but there's another two parts to the story, so I'll be creating the series thingy soon (I'm a complete novice at how you do all the stories/series things on this website, lol). The next part is called "In Your Shadow", and is pretty short, and the third part is called "Für Die Liebe Und Die Ehre", and isn't yet finished. So yeah, when I've finished uploading unendlichkeit, I'll set about putting up the next few!rnrn Finally, I had an idea for another TH fanfic last night, so I'll be writing that soon too. As for other stuff I've done, I have done other fanfic, but I tend to write in first person, and the style is much, much different from this one...but the strange thing is, these TH fanfics are the only fanfictions that I've ever finished (apart from one other, which I'm far too embarrassed to admit I wrote :). I don't mind sharing a few of my unfinished ones, but for now I think I'll stick to TH stories, since they seem to flow so much easier than the rest! rnrn So, again, thank you so much, and I'll be updating tomorrow (I think...it is mother's day tomorrow...oh dear). Oh, about the genre thing, I have no idea what the boundaries are for each category. I don't know what classes as slash, but Tom and Bill's relationship doesn't go further than what it is now, really, so I don't know whether that classes as slash :S Hmm...I'll have a look at the FAQ section, :D.rnrn THANK YOU!!! rnrn (P.S. I apologise for the weird long responses to your reviews, for some reason the website isn't recognising when I've hit the enter key for a new paragraph. I'll try and fix it :)
Date: 03/11/10 05:23 am Title: Chapter 4 - Blameless
Is that a 'cliffhanger'? I've never been properly good at recognising one, lol. Other than my ignorance about cliffhangers, seriously, thank you for thanking me, in the Chapter's notes. Twice. That actually made me blush, but really, you didn't have to, I'm just being a reviewer, nothing more and nothing less. But thanks though, I do appreciate it when you appreciate me, lol.
Moving on to the fic, in all honestly I've been thinking about it a lot during these last days, probably wondering why I'm the only reviewer. Truth be told, I considered the fact that maybe I was overestimating both the story and your style. Then again: truth be told, hell, no, I'm not! You're pretty damn talented at writing, that's for sure. That's what I think, clearly. I've already told you what I like about your style, there's no need to repeat. But this story is just too awesome not to get caught. See, I'm babbling. I'm moving on again.
As for this latest chapter. When I started reading, I knew that sooner or later I'd come across that side pairing, which turns out to be the pairing I'd never ever read in my life, Bill/Tom/OFC. Call it prejudice if you like. I can't promise you I'll like this Alex, but I do promise I'll follow you chapter by chapter, and if there's someone that has some chance to make me change my mind about OFCs, that an author like you I guess. So keep on going, 'kay? :)
That's your challenge, getting me to like Alex, lol.
(I was half-kidding, I would never be too harsh!).
Mmmmm. There's one thing about Bill that left me a little confusded in this one to be honest. So, he's lost his memory, right? He's mad because of that, and in that wonderful scene he goes mad because he can't recognise the stranger in the mirror as himself (*hearts*). So, now, so suddenly, he's ready to speak with Tom in a civil way? I don't know, maybe I was expecting him to stay mad. Or maybe I was expecting him to treat Tom like a complete stranger. I understand myself that, if Bill has no memory, he can't rely on anyone else but the one who claims to be his twin, so of course Bill should have accepted Tom's presence, sure, but maybe only a little later. If you know what I mean.
Just one point: I'm not saying, WTF?!?! NO! THIS IS ALL WRONG!, of course I'm not, as an author, you seem to know pretty well what you're doing, and what you want to do, so I'm sure that whenever I point things out, that'll just be me being a bit of a bitch. :) So don't worry, because I'm absolutely loving it, just tell me when I'm a bitch or ignore me.
To be honest, I didn't exactly understand what you mean by "There are a couple of references to the actual songs rather than stuff like the line you mentioned. They are necessary additions to the story to aid its progression, so when I upload the rest of the chapters, please let me know if you think some of it is too much, and I'll be sure to take that into consideration while I'm writing the last part", my bad. But once for all, I'm not AT ALL adversed to quotes, - like the ones in the beginning of each chapter -, in fact you'll never find someone who loves quotes from songs, books, movies, etc., more than me. It was just things like the line about the monsoon probably, that I'd like you to keep away from the paragraphs of the story, because otherwise I'm afraid the story will really lose some originality, for example if there's a mention to the monsoon. Especially with a reference to the monsoon. Sorry that was harsh and probably a little exaggerated, and that's just an opinion of mine, it's not that a single line will change my opinion about the story.
Oh! Tom is awesomeness. :) Just a few words: BEST SENSE OF GUILT I'VE EVER READ ABOUT. And I've read even a book about sense of guilt.
I'm waiting for the next part! :)
Author's Response: Okays, first things first :) Yep, I guess it's a cliffhanger. I think most of the chapters end with cliffhangers. I do that a lot when I write, lol. Next, about the character Alex, I haven't decided yet whether to try and make her a likeable character. In the part that I'm writing at the moment, which is the third part of this series, she's striking me as a bit sleezy, but I'm just writing as it comes to me. I don't know :) I guess I'll have to make sure the progression of the character is right. rnrnNext, about the really, really quick move from Bill being mad to suddenly being civil, the reason why it's so rushed is because this fic was meant to be pretty short (it's got eight chapters that are all about the same length) and when I wrote it I wasn't sure how long I should make it, so I tried not to make it too long. There is a possible explanation in a later chapter, where Bill says something like Tom was the only person he'd spoken to so far who hadn't been freaked out or abnormally calm or something like that. I'm not that good with my progression, I tend to hurry things because I write really quickly (usually to get the story out before I forget it :D)rnrnAnd NO WAY! You're not being a bitch at all! I look forward to reading your reviews. Hell, I even stay online for ages after I've uploaded a chapter waiting to read your review! You definitely deserved thanking so many times because you really, honestly boosted my confidence so much! A massive thank you!rnrnFinally, the song references, I think I might have rambled a little when I tried to explain, lol. Looking back at it, I think the line "if there had ever been a monsoon..." was out of place, so I totally understand that :D I guess the song references are more like the ones at the start of the chapter, just like little bits of the song. I'm hoping it'll all become clearer soon :D WOW I am so confusing! I confuse myself lol.rnrnAgain, thanks so much!! I'm so glad that you like it, and I'm really, really grateful for your reviews!rnrnTHANKS!
Date: 03/09/10 02:49 pm Title: Chapter 3 - Confusion
Oh wow, what's creeping me out like, right now is that less than a hour ago I wrote in another review, for another very different story, that I love mirrors in stories, I love it when a character sees their reflection and yet they see a stranger. I really don't mind the reason, I just know that's a wonderful subject, very difficult to deal with it indeed, but one of my favourites, that's for sure. This is why I'm creeped out now, because the beginning of the chapter is about that, lol.
So well yes, I liked all about that, about Bill not being able to recognise himself. It actually left me breathless. Despair is just pouring out from every sentence, and it's impossible, impossible not to get caught. Reading was a real suffering (in the positive sense =D), you're so good at showing readers all the scene; it seems that you don't leave anything out, you're telling us all the facts exactly for what they are, and that's great, really great. Believe me, I totally adore that.
You mantain a slow pace, that's another good thing. I hate rushed stories, and a proper rhythm is always appreciated, mostly because it makes the story more believable, I think. As I said, I'm enjoying so much how you keep things slow, it's as if you're showing us those harsh scenes almost brutally. Sure enough, they were three chapters for one scene. I wish you could hear me clap, because not many writers do that. I'm pleasantly surprised, and full of admiration at the same time (in fact it's easy for me to comment on fics, but I seriously doubt I'd be able to keep up with high standars myself).
I feel the need to point out that these are my standards, my OWN standards I mean. I liked the fact that you're surely taking your time to write it, but maybe other people would find it...I don't know...dragged, for example, if you know what I'm talking about. I bloody hope I'm making sense.
I effin' love psychological stories, and yours seems so good. Believe me, I really enjoy myself while reading, because you're a really original writer, and very convincing.
Now it looks like you've moved on Tom's point of view. That's okay, it seems he'll be dealing with a great sense of guilt, huh? Let me say, as a psychological stories lover, it's difficult to write about sense of guilt, I think. It's not that I'm an expert but I've recently coped with my worst sensation EVER of sense of guilt, I thought I was going to go crazy. So yeah, sense of guilt is another of my personal favourite subjects. You seem to know what you're doing with this story, so I can't really wait to see how you'll deal with Tom's sense of guilt, if that's what you're planning to write. :) Seriously, I can't wait.
Ohhh, there was something, actually...
"Bill tore at the wall and ripped the nail from his right index finger." - EW! Please tell me I misuderstood!
Oh, just one thing though. I'm extremely sorry but I just have to point it out.
"If there had ever been a monsoon..."
No. Please no, just no. I understand you're a fan (so am I), but noooo, please, I want their songs and verses out of stories like this! :(
(I was kidding. ...maybe not).
I checked out your profile, I read you're from the UK, so this story is written in English, as in English English. Mh, I'm practically in love with every English thing, seriously, don't ask me why. This story seems to be no exception, in fact. Considering how it got to me, I shouldn't be so surprised to find out about its English origin, haha.
I wanted to ask if you've ever written something else. I'd like to read some of other stories you've written--if you have, and of course if you don't mind.
Well, that was it. I'm waiting impatiently for the next part to come!
Author's Response: Hey again! Wow, thanks so much for everything you've said, it's all been really awesome and helpful! I'm glad you're enjoying it! First things first, I notice you said about the nail :) I figured that it was unlikely that he'd scratch at the wall and not at least break his nails. Maybe I was a little harsh, but a lot of my stories are horror or sci-fi based, and there tends to be a lot of blood and depression, as strange as that sounds, so it looks like it leaks into the rest of my stories. I'll try not to put too much of that sort of thing in if it seems out of place :) rnSecond thing, about the monsoon reference, I understand what you're saying about the song references. As far as plays on the song titles are concerned, I don't think I put any more into this part of the series, but there might be some later on. There are a couple of references to the actual songs rather than stuff like the line you mentioned. They are necessary additions to the story to aid its progression, so when I upload the rest of the chapters, please let me know if you think some of it is too much, and I'll be sure to take that into consideration while I'm writing the last part (which I'm doing right now :). I'm praying I won't let you down with how I deal with Tom's point of view. I've already written it, so I might go over it again and make sure it's up to scratch. rnI realised after I uploaded this chapter that I forgot to thank you in the opening notes, so I'll make sure that I do it when I upload the next chapter! rnFinally, the next chapter is going to start dealing with the "het" section of the story, but not too much, I hope. I'm still very much sticking to Tom/Bill, but I brought in the OFC for later reasons that involve the next two parts of the series.rnAgain, thanks so much, I'm glad you liked it, and just to answer your final question, yep, I do write other stuff. As I said, it's mostly grounded in sci-fi/horror, but I've written a few other fanfics as well for things like anime (Bleach) and other novels (such as Vernon God Little). I love writing and I hope one day to make a living from it, as big-headed as that sounds :) This is the first thing I've written that I've shared with anybody, so believe me when I say that absolutely everything you've said to me has been awesome and really helpful! I can't thank you enough, and you boosted my confidence in my writing. Words can't express how grateful I am! rnOne last thanks!!
Date: 03/08/10 01:09 pm Title: Chapter 2 - Curiosity
The only concrete problem with this fic is that it's not getting as many reviews as it should, or as I would expect it to. I admit that the genre is not my favourite maybe, but hell it's impossible to stop reading once you've started.
Your writing is extremely clean and original, - even brilliant perhaps -, I really really like it, it's incredibly fluent. Reading on just came naturally to me.
Now this is something really...different somehow, I'm interested to see where this is going. Maybe the pairings are not the ones that normally would get me hooked, but keep it going, I'm following it. :)
Author's Response: Thanks so much! This really means a lot to me, I hope I don't let you down! I'm planning to turn this into a three-part story, I've already got two parts written, so I'll hopefully be uploading the next chapter tomorrow. Thanks again!
